DEF: Consumers Bancorp Sets 2025 Annual Meeting Agenda

Sentiment:

Definitive Proxy Statement 5 September 2025 10:04 AM

📋All filings for Consumers Bancorp INC /OH/

Consumers Bancorp, Inc. announced its 2025 Annual Meeting of Shareholders to be held virtually, outlining proposals for director elections, executive compensation votes, and auditor ratification.

Worse than expectedNet income for fiscal year 2025 was $8,667,000, falling slightly short of the target of $8,840,700.The performance target for executive restricted stock units (return on average equity) was not achieved for fiscal year 2025, resulting in these units not vesting.

Summary

The Annual Meeting of Shareholders will be held virtually on Thursday, October 23, 2025, at 10:00 a.m. local time.
Shareholders will vote on the election of three Class I directors for a three-year term until 2028 and one Class I director for a term until 2026.
An advisory, non-binding resolution to approve the compensation of the company's named executive officers will be presented.
Shareholders will also vote on the frequency of future non-binding advisory votes on executive compensation, with the Board recommending a three-year frequency.
The appointment of Plante & Moran, PLLC as the independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2026, will be ratified.
As of August 29, 2025, 3,144,775 common shares were outstanding, with each share entitled to one vote.
The company reported net income of $8,667,000 for fiscal year 2025, a slight increase from $8,580,000 in 2024 but a decrease from $10,674,000 in 2023.
Total Shareholder Return (TSR) for a $100 investment was $126.59 in 2025, up from $95.11 in 2024 and $97.29 in 2023.

Sentiment

Score: 6

Explanation: The filing presents a mixed financial picture with some operational metrics exceeding targets (loans, deposits, efficiency, delinquency) but key profitability metrics (net income, ROAE for executive vesting) falling short of targets. Corporate governance appears stable and robust, but the overall financial performance for the past fiscal year shows a decline in net income from 2023 levels.

Positives

The company exceeded its target for gross loans, reaching $813,458,000 against a maximum target of $811,204,475 for fiscal year 2025.
The efficiency ratio of 70.84% for fiscal year 2025 was better than the target of 72.14%, indicating improved operational efficiency.
Delinquency rates were significantly lower than targets at 0.19% compared to a target of 0.88% and a threshold of 0.72%, reflecting strong credit quality.
Total deposits and customer repurchase agreements reached $1,052,329,000, surpassing the target of $1,009,564,725.
Total Shareholder Return (TSR) showed strong growth in 2025, with a $100 investment growing to $126.59, indicating positive shareholder value creation.
The Board of Directors maintains a strong independent composition, with all directors except the CEO identified as independent.
The company has a robust committee structure, with all directors attending at least 75% of board and committee meetings in fiscal year 2025.

Negatives

Net income for fiscal year 2025 was $8,667,000, which was below the target of $8,840,700, although it exceeded the threshold of $8,654,580.
The performance target for executive restricted stock units (return on average equity) was not achieved for fiscal year 2025, resulting in these units not vesting.
Net income has declined from $10,674,000 in 2023 to $8,667,000 in 2025, indicating a downward trend in profitability over the past two fiscal years.

Risks

The company faces inherent business risks including economic risks, financial risks, legal and regulatory risks, and the impact of competition.
The inability to provide the online registration option for all Beneficial Holders for the virtual Annual Meeting could impact participation, though it would not affect the meeting's validity.

Future Outlook

No material changes are expected to overall director compensation in fiscal year 2026. Restricted stock units awarded to non-employee directors in July 2025 are expected to vest in June 2026, contingent on meeting minimum attendance requirements. The Board recommends a three-year frequency for advisory votes on executive compensation to align with longer-term evaluation of compensation programs.

Management Comments

The Board believes the separation of offices of the Chairman and CEO is appropriate at this time as it allows our CEO to focus primarily on management and operating responsibilities.
The Board believes the company's compensation structure is effective in aligning the compensation of executive officers with short-term and long-term goals, and that such compensation and incentives are designed to attract, retain, and motivate executive officers.
The Board believes the director fees are competitive with those paid by other peer banks of comparable size and will ensure the company attracts and retains qualified Board members.
The Board recommends a shareholder vote every three years for the frequency of non-binding shareholder votes on executive compensation, believing it is the most appropriate timeframe to evaluate the company's overall compensation philosophy, design, and implementation.

Industry Context

The company's decision to hold a virtual Annual Meeting aligns with a broader industry trend towards digital shareholder engagement, offering convenience and accessibility. Its executive compensation practices, including base salary, incentive compensation, and long-term equity awards, are structured to be competitive with 'similar peer banks' and 'comparable financial institutions within the region of similar asset size,' reflecting standard practices in the banking sector to attract and retain talent. The emphasis on community involvement for board members supports the 'community bank philosophy' of its subsidiary, Consumers National Bank.

Comparison to Industry Standards

Director compensation is targeted at the market median (50th percentile) of comparable financial institutions within the region of similar asset size, based on a peer group analysis completed by Blanchard Consulting Group in fiscal year 2024.
Executive compensation is also targeted to the midpoint of its peer group, developed for compensation analysis by Blanchard Consulting Group, ensuring competitiveness within the banking industry.
The company's use of a Salary Continuation Program (SCP) for executive retention is a common non-qualified deferred compensation strategy in the financial industry.

Management Changes

Role	Previous Person	New Person	Effective Date	Reason
Chairman of the Boards	Laurie L. McClellan	Frank L. Paden	January 2024	Ms. McClellan's retirement from the position.
Vice Chairman of the Board	NA	Richard T. Kiko, Jr.	January 2024	Appointment to new role.
Class I Director	NA	David R. Bickerton	March 2025	Appointment to the Board.
Class III Director	NA	Joseph A. Gerzina	July 2024	Appointment by the Board of Directors.
Director	Harry W. Schmuck, Jr.	NA	October 2024	Retirement from the Board.
Executive Vice President, Chief Credit Officer	NA	Suzanne Mikes	September 2024	Appointment to new role.

Corporate Governance

Change Type	Description	Effective Date	Impact Assessment
Meeting Format	The Annual Meeting of Shareholders will be held exclusively virtually via live webcast, with no physical in-person meeting.	October 23, 2025	Increases accessibility for shareholders but requires online access and technical familiarity; specific registration procedures for beneficial holders are outlined.
Board Leadership Structure	The offices of Chairman and CEO are separated, with Frank L. Paden serving as Chairman and Ralph J. Lober II as CEO.	January 2024 (Chairman appointment)	Allows the CEO to focus primarily on management and operating responsibilities, potentially enhancing strategic focus and oversight.
Committee Appointments	Bradley Goris was appointed to the Executive Committee in January 2025. John W. Parkinson was appointed to the Corporate Governance/Nominating Committee in January 2025. David R. Bickerton joined the Asset/Liability Committee, Audit Committee, and Risk & Technology Committee following his appointment to the Board in March 2025. Joseph A. Gerzina joined the Audit Committee, Loan Committee, and Corporate Governance/Nominating Committee following his appointment to the Board in July 2024. Laurie L. McClellan became chairperson of the Loan Committee in November 2024.	Various dates in FY2025	Reflects ongoing adjustments to committee composition to leverage director expertise and maintain effective oversight following retirements and new appointments.
Director Retirement Policy	Frank L. Paden, a Class I director, is nominated to serve until the 2026 annual meeting due to the company's mandatory retirement age policy.	Ongoing policy	Ensures periodic refreshment of the Board while allowing for continued contribution from experienced directors for a transitional period.
Insider Trading Policy	Prohibits executive officers and directors from buying or selling company securities when aware of material, non-public information, purchasing on margin, engaging in short sales, or buying/selling derivative securities.	In effect	Enhances ethical conduct and compliance with securities laws, protecting the integrity of the company's stock and investor confidence.

Related Party Transactions

Loans are made to officers and directors on substantially the same terms as those prevailing at the same time for comparable transactions with unrelated third parties, and do not involve more than normal risk of collectability or other unfavorable features.
The company retained the services of Kiko Auctioneers and Kiko Real Estate Brokerage, associated with director Richard T. Kiko, Jr., for less than $120,000 in each of the 2024 and 2025 fiscal years.

Stakeholder Impact

Shareholders: Will participate in key governance decisions, including director elections and executive compensation, and receive information on company performance and future outlook.
Employees: Benefit from a 401(k) plan with company matching contributions and, for executive and senior management, a Salary Continuation Program designed for retention.
Customers: The company's strong loan and deposit growth, coupled with low delinquency rates, indicates a healthy banking operation that serves its customer base effectively.
Directors and Executive Officers: Compensation is tied to company performance, with specific metrics influencing incentive payments and equity vesting, aligning their interests with shareholder value. Board composition and committee assignments are detailed, ensuring robust oversight.

Next Steps

Shareholders to attend the virtual Annual Meeting on October 23, 2025, to vote on proposals.
Shareholders to consider the Board's recommendation for a three-year frequency for advisory votes on executive compensation.
The Audit Committee will reconsider the appointment of Plante & Moran, PLLC if shareholders do not ratify it, but may decide to maintain the appointment.
Shareholders intending to present proposals for the 2026 Annual Meeting must submit them by May 18, 2026 (for inclusion in proxy statement) or July 27, 2026 (otherwise).

Key Dates

Date	Description
October 1987	Laurie L. McClellan began serving as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
September 1995	Consumers National Bank's Board of Directors adopted a non-qualified salary continuation plan (SCP).
March 1998	Laurie L. McClellan began serving as Chairman of the Boards.
January 2008	Ralph J. Lober II was promoted to President and appointed to Consumers National Bank's Board of Directors.
September 2008	Ralph J. Lober II was named Chief Executive Officer.
January 2011	Bradley Goris began serving as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
July 2013	Frank L. Paden began serving as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
January 2015	Richard T. Kiko, Jr. began serving as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
January 1, 2020	John W. Parkinson was appointed to serve as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
March 2021	Michael A. Wheeler and Shawna L. LItalien began serving as Directors of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
January 2023	Ann M. Gano was appointed by the Board of Directors as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
January 1, 2024	Laurie L. McClellan retired as Chairman of the Boards; Frank L. Paden was appointed Chairman; Richard T. Kiko, Jr. was appointed Vice Chairman.
July 1, 2024	Restricted stock units were issued to all directors, settled on June 30, 2025. Restricted stock units were also issued to executive officers, but did not vest due to missed performance target.
July 2024	Joseph A. Gerzina was appointed by the Board of Directors as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
August 2024	Suzanne Mikes received her Certified Exit Planning Advisor certification.
September 2024	Suzanne Mikes was appointed Executive Vice President, Chief Credit Officer.
October 2024	Harry W. Schmuck, Jr. retired from the Board.
November 2024	Laurie L. McClellan became chairperson of the Loan Committee.
November 2024	Ralph J. Lober II received his Certified Exit Planning Advisor certification.
January 2025	Bradley Goris was appointed to the Executive Committee; John W. Parkinson was appointed to the Corporate Governance/Nominating Committee.
February 2025	One Form 4 for Mr. Goris was unintentionally filed late, reporting the purchase of shares of common stock.
March 2025	David R. Bickerton began serving as a Director of Consumers Bancorp, Inc. and Consumers National Bank.
June 30, 2025	End of fiscal year 2025. Market value of unvested restricted stock awards determined by closing price of $20.00 per share.
August 29, 2025	Record date for shareholders entitled to notice of and to vote at the Annual Meeting.
September 5, 2025	Date of the Notice of Annual Meeting of Shareholders.
On or about September 10, 2025	Proxy Statement and accompanying proxy first mailed to shareholders of record.
October 17, 2025	Deadline for Beneficial Holders to submit proof of proxy power for advance registration to attend the virtual Annual Meeting (5:00 p.m., Eastern Time).
October 23, 2025	Date of the Annual Meeting of Shareholders (10:00 a.m. local time).
June 30, 2026	End of fiscal year 2026. Restricted stock units awarded in July 2025 will vest if minimum attendance requirements are met.
July 27, 2026	Deadline for shareholders to deliver written notice to nominate a director candidate for the 2026 Annual Meeting (other than for inclusion in proxy statement).
May 18, 2026	Deadline for shareholders to deliver proposals for inclusion in Consumers Bancorp's proxy statement for the 2026 Annual Meeting.

Recommendation

hold

The filing is a routine proxy statement for an annual meeting, primarily detailing governance matters, director elections, and executive compensation. While it includes financial performance data for the past fiscal year, this information would have been previously disclosed in the company's 10-K filing. The financial results are mixed, with some operational metrics exceeding targets but net income slightly missing its target and executive equity awards not vesting due to missed performance. There are no new material strategic announcements or significant changes that would immediately impact the company's valuation or share price. Therefore, a 'hold' recommendation is appropriate as the filing does not present new information warranting a change in investment thesis.

Keywords

Banking, Financial Services, Proxy Statement, Corporate Governance, Executive Compensation, Director Election, Audit, Shareholder Meeting, Net Income, Loan Growth, Deposit Growth, Efficiency Ratio, Delinquency

Disclaimer:The information provided here is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice, recommendation, or endorsement of any kind. It may contain errors or omissions. You should not rely on this information to make financial decisions. Always seek the advice of a qualified financial professional before making any investment or financial decisions. Use of this information is at your own risk.